Insurance Carrier
Mutual of Omaha
You have worked your entire life building toward retirement, and when a real health event happens - a hospitalization, a surgery, a specialist you actually need - the last thing you should be doing is calculating what 20% of an uncapped bill looks like. Mutual of Omaha has been the company people turn to in exactly that moment since 1909, and their A+ (Superior) AM Best financial strength rating reflects over 115 years of actually paying claims, not just collecting premiums. If the name of the company backing your Medigap policy matters to you - and it should - Mutual of Omaha is one of the few carriers in this market whose track record is long enough to speak for itself.
There are reasons why Mutual of Omaha keeps coming up when agents, advisors, and Medicare beneficiaries ask which carriers have genuinely stood the test of time in the Medigap market. They are consistently ranked among the top Medicare Supplement carriers in the country by enrollment, they hold an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best - the insurance industry’s most recognized financial strength benchmark - and they have been paying claims through every recession, market disruption, and healthcare cost spike since Woodrow Wilson was president. That is not marketing copy; it is a documented 115-year track record that very few insurance companies of any kind can match, let alone in Medicare Supplement specifically.
What Mutual of Omaha Is Known For
A+ (Superior) AM Best financial strength rating - one of the highest ratings possible and a reflection of Mutual of Omaha’s long-term claims-paying reliability across more than a century of operation
Founded in 1909 and headquartered in Omaha, Nebraska - one of the most recognized insurance names in America, with over 115 years of continuous history serving policyholders through every economic and healthcare environment
Medicare Supplement plan options typically include Plan G, High-Deductible Plan G, and Plan N - among the most widely selected Medigap plan letters for new Medicare beneficiaries today - where available by state
Household discount available in most states where Mutual of Omaha Medigap policies are offered - typically applied when another eligible adult in the same household is also insured, which can meaningfully reduce the annual premium cost for couples
No provider network restrictions on any Medicare Supplement policy - policyholders can see any doctor, specialist, or hospital that accepts Original Medicare anywhere in the United States without referrals or network approvals
Member Perks & How to Use Them
A Medicare Supplement policy from Mutual of Omaha does not come with OTC cards or gym memberships - what it comes with is structural freedom that most people do not fully appreciate until they need it. No networks to navigate, no claims to file, no referrals to chase down, and coverage that follows you anywhere in the country. Understanding exactly how the policy works in practice is what separates people who get full value from their Medigap plan from those who wonder whether they made the right choice.
How to use your Mutual of Omaha Medigap policy: At every medical appointment, hospital, or specialist visit, present both your red, white, and blue Medicare card and your Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement ID card. Medicare processes the claim first - Mutual of Omaha automatically pays its share of the approved amount, with no claims for you to file in most situations
No provider network - complete freedom of choice: With a Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement policy, you can see any doctor, specialist, or hospital that accepts Original Medicare anywhere in the United States - no referrals required, no network restrictions, no penalties for choosing any Medicare-participating provider
Household discount: In most states, Mutual of Omaha offers a household discount when another eligible adult in your household is also insured. Ask your agent whether you qualify and what the percentage discount is in your specific state - this can make a meaningful difference in your combined annual premium
Prescription coverage - add a standalone Part D plan: Medicare Supplement policies do not include prescription drug coverage. Your agent can help you select and enroll in a standalone Medicare Part D prescription drug plan alongside your Medigap policy - this is a necessary step to keep your prescriptions covered
Nationwide coverage while traveling: Your Mutual of Omaha Medigap policy covers Medicare-approved care at any Medicare-accepting provider in all 50 states - if you winter in Florida, summer in Maine, or travel regularly, you carry the same coverage everywhere you go
Availability
Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement plans are available in most states across the country. Medigap is not available in Massachusetts, Minnesota, or Wisconsin, which operate their own standardized supplemental coverage systems. Plan letter availability, premium rates, household discount eligibility, and underwriting rules vary by state and age - confirm what is available in your ZIP code with a licensed agent before comparing options.
What to Verify Before Enrolling
Choosing a Medigap policy is not a decision you should make based on a rate card alone - the plan letter, your enrollment timing, your household situation, and your prescription coverage all interact in ways that matter more than most people realize until after they have signed. Work through each of these checkpoints before you commit so the only surprise you encounter is how smoothly the coverage actually works.
- ✓
Confirm which Medicare Supplement plan letters - such as Plan G, High-Deductible Plan G, or Plan N - are currently available through Mutual of Omaha in your specific state, as plan letter availability varies by state filing and approval
- ✓
Request a current premium quote for your exact age, gender, tobacco status, and ZIP code - Medigap rates vary by these factors and can differ substantially from one location to another even within the same state
- ✓
Ask whether you qualify for the household discount and what the specific percentage is in your state - eligibility criteria and discount amounts vary by state, and confirming this upfront can affect your total annual premium meaningfully
- ✓
Clarify whether you are in your Medigap Open Enrollment Period - the six-month window beginning on your Part B effective date - since this is the period when Mutual of Omaha must accept your application regardless of health history; outside this window, medical underwriting applies and prior conditions may affect eligibility
- ✓
Since Medicare Supplement plans do not include prescription drug coverage, confirm you have a separate standalone Part D prescription drug plan selected alongside your Medigap policy - without a Part D plan, outpatient prescription costs remain fully out of pocket
Contact Mutual of Omaha Directly
If you are already a Mutual of Omaha policyholder and have a question about your coverage, a claim, or your billing, their member services team is your authoritative source - not a summary page, not an estimate. If you are still comparing options, the carrier website is the right place to verify current plan availability and pull official materials. Use the contact information below and have your member ID ready when you call.
Member Services
1-800-228-9999Mailing Address
Mutual of Omaha Mutual of Omaha Plaza Omaha, NE 68175
Contact information is provided for reference and may change. Always verify current contact details on Mutual of Omaha’s official website or your plan materials.
Benefits Vary by Plan, County, and Eligibility
Plan availability varies by county and ZIP code. Benefits, premiums, copayments, provider networks, formularies, and rules vary by plan and may change. Always review official plan materials before enrolling.
Check Mutual of Omaha Availability in Your Area
The right Medigap plan - one that closes the gaps Original Medicare leaves open without locking you into a network or requiring you to manage your own claims - may already be available through Mutual of Omaha in your ZIP code. A licensed agent will pull current plan letters, run your actual premium quote, and walk you through whether the household discount applies to your situation before you make any decision.
Quick Medicare Review
Enter your details and a licensed agent will reach out to you.